{
  "payload": {
    "schema_version": "capas-claim-payload-v3",
    "claim": {
      "id": "brief_fin_001",
      "type": "financial_metric_claim",
      "text": "Reported net assets of 1000 match the audited reference for the period."
    },
    "evidence": {
      "reported_value": 1000,
      "reference_value": 1000,
      "tolerance": 0.5,
      "metric_period_match": true,
      "invariants": {
        "accounting": {
          "assets": 1000,
          "liabilities": 600,
          "equity": 300
        }
      }
    }
  },
  "result": {
    "schema_version": "capas-claim-payload-v3",
    "input_claim": {
      "id": "brief_fin_001",
      "type": "financial_metric_claim",
      "text": "Reported net assets of 1000 match the audited reference for the period."
    },
    "verdict": "REJECT",
    "reason": "reported_value differs from reference_value by 0.0, within tolerance 0.5, and period matches; OVERRIDDEN by a domain invariant violation: balance identity VIOLATED: assets 1000.0 != liabilities 600.0 + equity 300.0 (residual 100) — the books do not close",
    "licensed_claim": null,
    "rewrite": null,
    "missing_fields": [],
    "required_fields": [
      "reported_value",
      "reference_value",
      "tolerance",
      "metric_period_match"
    ],
    "schema_errors": [],
    "did_you_mean": {},
    "resolution": {
      "kind": "exclude_or_replace_evidence",
      "message": "The evidence contradicts the claim. Exclude it, or supply new evidence that changes the contract outcome."
    },
    "invariant_audit": {
      "applicable": true,
      "verdict": "FLAG",
      "laws_checked": [
        "accounting"
      ],
      "violations": [
        "accounting"
      ],
      "holds": [],
      "results": {
        "accounting": {
          "applies": true,
          "verdict": "FLAG",
          "law": "assets = liabilities + equity",
          "why": "balance identity VIOLATED: assets 1000.0 != liabilities 600.0 + equity 300.0 (residual 100) — the books do not close"
        }
      },
      "summary": "balance identity VIOLATED: assets 1000.0 != liabilities 600.0 + equity 300.0 (residual 100) — the books do not close"
    },
    "text_licensed_as_written": false,
    "notices": [
      "ai_use_declared: not declared (tool, purpose, phase); required from the X6 freeze"
    ],
    "plan3_checks": {
      "provenance": {
        "declared": 0,
        "verified": 0
      },
      "ai_use_declared": "not declared",
      "uncertainty": "not declared"
    },
    "fine_tune_ready": false,
    "fine_tune_blockers": [
      "claim verdict is not ACCEPT",
      "source-backed evidence is not attached",
      "external review is not attached",
      "claim.text semantic alignment is not externally certified",
      "witness independence is not externally certified",
      "provenance.sources or provenance.source_urls is empty",
      "external review hash is missing or does not match review_packet",
      "source URLs are not recoverable with matching hashes",
      "witness_id is not resolvable in the witness registry",
      "RO-Crate provenance packet is missing, invalid, or hash-mismatched",
      "reviewer identity or attestation is not verifiable",
      "provenance.review_id is missing",
      "provenance.witness_id is missing"
    ],
    "fine_tune_criteria": {
      "verdict_accept": false,
      "schema_clean": true,
      "source_backed_evidence": false,
      "external_review": false,
      "semantic_alignment": false,
      "witness_independence": false,
      "provenance_sources": false,
      "review_hash_verified": false,
      "source_urls_recoverable_hashable": false,
      "witness_registry_resolved": false,
      "ro_crate_validated": false,
      "reviewer_attestation_verified": false,
      "review_id_present": false,
      "witness_id_present": false
    },
    "non_claim": "This decision is rule-based over supplied evidence fields, not an LLM judgment.",
    "audit_hash": "sha256:4a323d7445b6bb14a5ae30d008d5606e5482fcec3db2b986b9b6613509ac5997",
    "rules_fired": [
      "R404ebcc1d2",
      "R498daec9f1"
    ],
    "rule_table_sha256": "sha256:f871e061eb2690b9cc376b5fb07bc6f2d5affbe3de3cc343a16f5dd394cc3dd6",
    "engine_version": "0.4.1",
    "evidence_sha256": "sha256:5c52b7088b555b950f9bf3b373bb062ee681c80475b33d75b835ee99d390664a",
    "audit_hash_recipe": "v2",
    "admissibility_certificate": {
      "calculus_version": "capas-admissibility-calculus-v1",
      "metaphor": "compiler_certificate",
      "claim_contract": {
        "registered": true,
        "claim_type": "financial_metric_claim",
        "description": "Financial metric claims against a reference value and period. With evidence.ledger {rows_csv, metric, period} the engine recomputes reference_value from the rows itself.",
        "required_fields": [
          "reported_value",
          "reference_value",
          "tolerance",
          "metric_period_match"
        ],
        "optional_fields": [
          "metric_name",
          "audit_trail",
          "ledger",
          "object_declared",
          "object_matches_target",
          "load_bearing_citation_read",
          "citation_hypotheses_checked",
          "null_control_passed",
          "ai_use_declared",
          "coverage_factor",
          "abs_error_u",
          "tolerance_u",
          "method_standard",
          "cited_dois",
          "retraction_snapshot",
          "cited_doi_retracted",
          "prereg"
        ],
        "anchor_mode": null,
        "anchor_license": null,
        "absolute_accept_only": false
      },
      "lattice": {
        "axes": {
          "contract": {
            "score": 3,
            "level": "contract_complete"
          },
          "evidence": {
            "score": 2,
            "level": "complete"
          },
          "boundary": {
            "score": 2,
            "level": "claim_excluded"
          },
          "provenance": {
            "score": 0,
            "level": "none"
          },
          "defeaters": {
            "score": 4,
            "level": "no_active_defeater"
          }
        },
        "controlled_reuse_meet": 2,
        "training_reuse_meet": 0,
        "reuse_boundary": "claim_excluded",
        "non_claim": "This lattice orders admissibility of supplied evidence, not scientific truth."
      },
      "dialectic": {
        "thesis": "Reported net assets of 1000 match the audited reference for the period.",
        "licensed_thesis": null,
        "warrant": "reported_value differs from reference_value by 0.0, within tolerance 0.5, and period matches; OVERRIDDEN by a domain invariant violation: balance identity VIOLATED: assets 1000.0 != liabilities 600.0 + equity 300.0 (residual 100) — the books do not close",
        "supports": [
          "evidence.reported_value",
          "evidence.reference_value",
          "evidence.tolerance",
          "evidence.metric_period_match"
        ],
        "optional_supports": [],
        "undercutters": [],
        "rebuttals": [
          "reported_value differs from reference_value by 0.0, within tolerance 0.5, and period matches; OVERRIDDEN by a domain invariant violation: balance identity VIOLATED: assets 1000.0 != liabilities 600.0 + equity 300.0 (residual 100) — the books do not close"
        ],
        "burden_of_proof": []
      },
      "proof_obligations": [],
      "next_action": {
        "kind": "exclude_or_replace_evidence",
        "label": "Exclude this claim or provide new evidence that changes the contract outcome."
      }
    }
  }
}